Mereka yang maseh tidak puas berbahas isu "Islam Quran sahaja" bolehlah berhujah di ruang komen.
Mazhab Syiah dan Qadiani juga di persilakan berhujah, mempertahankan Islam mereka.
# This post is for Muslims who wish to debate and defend, refute and share their version or other versions/mazhab of Islam.
Those who still wish to debate on Quran only Islam are welcome to debate at the comments collomn.
Shiah and Qadiani Muslims too are welcome to debate on their religion.
Quran only Islam
This is the original Islam that is based on the Quran only. The reason for the Quran only as the source of Islamic law and belief is because ..
1) the hadis is considered hearsay or non witness reports of people who lived 300 years after the prophet died. The "isnad and matan" of hearsay hadis is but a dogma conjectured/fabricated by hadis Ulamas wishing to upgrade/sell/market/propogate their hearsay hadis to be accepted.
2) There is historical evidence including hadis,that the prophet Mohamad(s.a.w) banned and burned the hadis. The hadis ban remained at least 200 years arter the prophet Mohammad died.Refer,, http://warongpakyeh.blogspot.com/2012/09/the-ban-burn-of-hadis.html
3) There are verses in the Quran that discourage the use of hadis other than the Quran.ie
i) Quran 31:6 "Some people use "lahwal hadis" to mislead others from Allah's path,without knowledge, and mack a mockery of it(Allah's path/Islam)".
ii) Quran 12:40 "Surely the ‘HUKM’ (Law and Rule) is for none but Allah."
iii) Quran 18:26 "He does not make any one(not even the prophet Mohammad) His associate in His ‘HUKM’ (Laws and Ruling)."
4) The existence of illogical and contradicting hadis, such as..
i) the Israk mikraj hadis that blaspheme Allah saying that Allah flip flopped when he planned 50 solats a day and had to bring down the number to 5 solats aday after many haggling with prophet Mohammad.
ii) The hadis from monkeys stoning adulterers to death.
iii) The hajar aswat hadis that allows paganism, ie worshiping/kissing of a stone.
5) The Shiah and Sunni versions of hadis caused divisions/sects and mazhabs. The rootcause of this division is the belief in the Imam Mahadi that has a similiarity to Christian Jesus 2nd Coming mythology.