Wednesday, January 22, 2014

Why does Zuhur And Asar Contradicts Quran 17:110.?

Muslims must answer these questions before they die.!!!

1) Why is Zuhur and Asar solat silent.??? 

2) Why does Zuhur and Asar solat contradict Quran 17:110 "..... And thou (Muhammad), be not loud-voiced in thy worship nor yet silent therein, but follow a way between.".??? 

3) Does this mean that Zuhur and Asara is disqualified as a Quran solat.???

4) Is it not kufur to contradict Allah.???

5) Does this make us kafir to solat in a way contradicting allah.???

6) Does this not make the hadis Ulamas who taught us solats that contradict Allah, equal to Allah (shirik).???

7) Why are we not referring to the Quran for our true unadulterated solats.???


Syed Akhbar said...

Zohor and Asar prayer is not contradict AlQuran.
It was cleary mention.
Anyway we have Prophet Muhammad SAW as our Massanger .We follow what exactly Rasuallah Pray.
Five time a day including Zuhur and Azar.
prophet Muhammad was the Iman of the prayer when he alive.

Nik aziz said...

Assalamu alaikum wa rahmatullahi wa barakatuhu..
Thank you very much for your letter as usual, and thank you very much for having confidence on me.
Regarding your question about the Qur’anic verse which concludes five times daily prayers..,
I say that there is no single Qur’anic verse which has mentioned all five times daily prayers in one place. We have to use the general thematic methodology in the Holy Qur’an. However, there are several Qur’anic verses in different chapters have mentioned all five time daily prayers. The following verses are the clear prove and strong evidence for our five time daily prayers.
Also the authentic pratical Sunnah of prophet Muhammed peace be upon him as shown and taught us that we should pray five times a day, not like some Islamic deviated fractions which refuse five times prayer.
The following verses are to be taken seriousely:
1- The almighty Allah swt in tha chapter Taha, verse 130, says:
( فَاصْبِرْ عَلَىٰ مَا يَقُولُونَ وَسَبِّحْ بِحَمْدِ رَبِّكَ قَبْلَ طُلُوعِ الشَّمْسِ وَقَبْلَ غُرُوبِهَا ۖ وَمِنْ آنَاءِ اللَّيْلِ فَسَبِّحْ وَأَطْرَافَ النَّهَارِ لَعَلَّكَ تَرْضَىٰ [٢٠:١٣٠] )
[en.maududi] So bear patiently with what they say. Glorify your Lord, praising Him before sunrise and before sunset,( Subuh and Asar), and in the watches of the night,(I’sha), and glorify Him and at the ends of the day that you may attain to happiness.

In this verse is mentioned: Subuh prayer + Asar+ I’sha prayer..

2- The second verse below (chapter Al A’raf, verse no;205) is indicated:
( وَاذْكُر رَّبَّكَ فِي نَفْسِكَ تَضَرُّعًا وَخِيفَةً وَدُونَ الْجَهْرِ مِنَ الْقَوْلِ بِالْغُدُوِّ وَالْآصَالِ وَلَا تَكُن مِّنَ الْغَافِلِينَ ) [٧:٢٠٥]
[en.ahmedraza] And remember your Lord within your hearts humbly and with fear, and softly with your tongues, morning (subuh) and evening, (maghrib) and do not be of the neglectful
In this verse: is indicated clearly Subuh + Maghrib prayers

In this verse below, In the chapter Al Isra’, verse no:78, the Almighty Allah says:
) أَقِمِ الصَّلَاةَ لِدُلُوكِ الشَّمْسِ إِلَىٰ غَسَقِ اللَّيْلِ وَقُرْآنَ الْفَجْرِ ۖ إِنَّ قُرْآنَ الْفَجْرِ كَانَ مَشْهُودًا([١٧:٧٨]
[en.ahmedraza] Keep the prayer established, from the declining of the sun (Zuhur), until darkness of the night(Asar), and the Qur’an at dawn (Fajar); indeed the angels witness the reading of the Qur’an at dawn.

Here is indicated clearly, the time of Zuhur prayer+Asar+Subuh.

In this verse below,chapter Al Nur, verse 24, the Almighty Allah says:
( فِي بُيُوتٍ أَذِنَ اللَّهُ أَن تُرْفَعَ وَيُذْكَرَ فِيهَا اسْمُهُ يُسَبِّحُ لَهُ فِيهَا بِالْغُدُوِّ وَالْآصَالِ [٢٤:٣٦])
[en.maududi] (Those who obtain guidance to His light are found) in the houses which He has enjoined to raise up and to mention His name therein. In them such people glorify Him morning and evening

Confirmation on what has been said above.

I do hope I answered your question, and Allah swt knows the best.

pak yeh said...

Dear Syed Akbar.
The silent solat clearly contradict the Quran 18:110. Thus Zuhur and Asar is not a Rasullullah's solat. The Rasul of Allah cannot contradict the Quran. Obviously it is the hadis solat. all hadis that contradict the Quran comes from disbelievers (kafir) of the Quran/Allah.

pak yeh said...

Dear Nik Aziz,
You are not bebating the issue/question. Why does the Zuhur and Asar silent solat contradict Allah/Quran 17:110.???
Can you please answer the question.
Why are you defendint silent solat that contradicts Allah/Quran 17/110.???

Mr Bojangles said...

Nik Aziz misses the point or goes on a merry frolic of his own while Syed Akhbar is difficult to understand.
Maybe that is the way of Muslims today, to be deliberately obfuscative in their attempt to sound profound.

Or maybe their words are so full of wisdom that they are beyond the ken of mere mortals like me

Borhan said...

Nither Syed Ali or Nik Aziz miss the point.

They are saying Zohor /Asar prayer does not contradic Quran.
The muslim follow Hoe the prophet Muhamnad saw pray Zohor and Asar.

Dont tell me 1 billion muslim around the world make a mistak in their Zohor/Asar prayer.

Only Pak Yeh try to be different from other praticing muslim.

Anonymous said...

Awat hang ni kelabu pi belajar dengan guru lah nak debat dalam blog hang buat apa lol.....
Tanya mufti PERAK la....

Anonymous said...

Pak Yeh,

If you see fit to reject the Hadith about the five daily prayers and refers only to the Quran, then how do you pray ?

Does the Quran tell you what to recite in your ruku' or sujud ? How about the rakaats ? Does the Quran tell you that ?

Of course not. Therefore can I ask how do you pray ?

You talk about solat but how do YOU do it ?

The fact is the Quran keeps on telling the Muslims to solat.Yet it leaves out vital details.

Did Allah forget ? Or did the Prophet forget or deliberately omit the information ?

Of course not. To say or believe otherwise is to reject what Allah Himself say about Him protecting the Quran and about Him perfecting Islam.

Therefore Allah did not forget and the Prophet delivered all that he told to deliver about the Quran.

So how does that solve the problem about the vital information about solat, fasting, haj, zakat etc ?

The answer is the hadith.

Indeed, if the Quran is supposed to be by itself - without the Hadith - then explain why it was revealed little by little over 23 years ?

If the Quran was supposed to be enough by itself, why didn't Allah just revealed everything in one go ?

The reason is simple and you know this - it is because to allow the Prophet to put Islam into practice. So that the Prophet can fill in the DETAILS such as how many RAKAATs, what to recite and so forth.

The moment you reject Hadith, you render Islam unworkable. The moment you reject Hadith, you render yourself unable to do solat, to fast, to do haj, how to pay zakah etc.

Think about it. Also, I hope you won't moderate this comment and any future replies to your rebuttals.

Ahmad Solihin Badyan

pak yeh said...

Anonymous said...
Pak Yeh,
If you see fit to reject the Hadith about the five daily prayers and refers only to the Quran, then how do you pray ?
Does the Quran tell you what to recite in your ruku' or sujud ? How about the rakaats ? Does the Quran tell you that ?
Of course not. Therefore can I ask how do you pray ?

Pak Yeh answer : How di Muslims pray for 250 years before Bukhari Muslim published their hadis bookso.without the hadis.???
So you see to say that you cannot pray without the hadis is bunkum bullshit. The prophet Mohamad taught us to pray through his example/sunnah guided/explained by the Quran, on how to wuduk,times of prayer,,and glorifying Allah by standing,rukuk and sujud repeatef twice(rakaat. The Quran says it is comp,ete. That means it does not need another persom or book to explain it. Similarly fasting and zakat was taught by the prophet using the Quran and his example/sunnah. The sunnah does not come from hadis but from Quran. Hadis is a book that contains monkey saying and lies written by Satans advocate.

Anonymous said...

Pada pencinta2 Hadis Bukhari/Muslim. Kau orang sanggup percaya kepada Hadis2 yang karut marut dan tak logic langsong. Sedangkan Allah kata Quran Dia complete/terperinci kamu tak terima.

Kamu tak akan dapat cerita2 dongeng seperti hadis dibawah ni didalam Quran.

Jabir r.a berkata,Rasulullah SAW pernah menyampaikan khutbah dan ceramahnya sambil memegang sebatang pokok kurma.Seorang wanita telah mencadangkan kepada baginda dan erkata,"Ya Rasulullah,mahukah engkau kami dirikan sebuah mimbar?"Baginda menjawab,"Jika kalian memang menginginkannya,silalah!"

Maka para sahabat pun membuatkan sebuah mimbar untuk Rasulullah SAW.Pada hari Jumaat,baginda SAW melangkah menuju mimbar itu.Tiba-tiba pokok kurma yang biasa digunakan oleh Nabi SAW menangis.Rasulullah SAW segera turun dari atas mimbar dan memeluk batang pokok itu.Pokok itu menangis seperti seorang bayi dan Rasulullah SAW telah memujuknya supaya diam.

Jabir r.a selanjutnya berkata:"Batang pokok kurma itu menangis bila mendengar orang membaca zikir atau mendengar al-Quran dibacakan di hadapannya."(Riwayat Bukhari)

Hadis diatas mengalahkan cerita "Alice in wonderland".

Gunakan otak yang tuhan bagitu untok berfikir. Kalau ikut ulama kau orang tak dibenarkan berfikir.


a r sulaiman said...

Hahaha..lawak ar hadis ni. Org islam hari ni sbb sayangkan nabj muhammad..apa saja cerita x kira masuk akal ke tidak semuanya dihadam x tengok kiri kanan.