1) Like the Christian Gospels, the Muslim Hadith were written by NON WITNESSES who lived 150 - 200 years after their prophets died.
Statements or hadiths by NON WITNESSES about their prophets is never accepted as TRUTH in any court of law because they only hear it from others and never witnessed it. The nature of their statements is "hearsay" or "gossip" by non witnesses like themselves.
The word of Allah in the Quran is the religion of Allah.
The word of man or hadith of Ulamas are what Allah says, lahwal hadith..Q31:6"Some people use lahwal (fake) hadith to mis;ead others from Allah's path(Islam) ...and make a mockery of it (Islam). For them is a painful doom"
Checkmate.!!!
2) The hadith Contradicts the Quran.
Muslims who contradict the Quran are Kafir.
The folowing are the proofs.
2.1) Allah / Quran saysthat the wuduk Q5:5 involves 4parts of the body. but the hadith Ulamas say wuduk involve 8 parts of the body.Hadith Muslim who reject or rubbish binned Allahs words Q5:6 and take the Ulamas word on wuduk have rejected Allah and takeh the Hadith Ulamas as their god.
2.2)Similarly Hadith Muslims have rejected or rubbish binned Allah's 3 times salat as per Q11:114 and taken the Ulamas word thats says 5 times solat negotiated a donkey flyig prophet after the fake Allah of the hadith foolishly prescribed 50 solats a day, which is an impossible target.
2.3) The hadith that says "Kill the apostate / There is compulsion in religion" contradicts the Quran Q2:256 "There is no compulsion in the deen/religion".
Therefore the Hadith Islam is not Islam of Allah of the Quran but the religion of Hadith Ulamas who made themselves gods besides Allah and a new religion disguised as Islam.
Checkmate.!!!
10 comments:
Pak Yeh, nampak sangat anda masih jahil mengenai ilmu mengenai hadith dan Al-Quran. Kalau tidak tahu belajar lagi, jangan buat tafsiran sendiri mengenai hadith tanpa ilmu, kerana syaitan akan menjadi guru anda. Anda mahu mejadi pengganti Kassim Ahmad? Dan didakwa di mahkamah syariah kerana menyebarkan pemikiran sesat?
Adalah menjadi harapan saya agar pemilik blog ini tidak menjadi penyambung lidah syaitan, perbahasan tentang perkara ini telah lama berlaku, jika pemilik blog ini tidak mempunyai jawapan terhadap soalan yang dikemukakan eloklah abaikan soalan itu. Sedikit pengetahuan tentang sebab sebab turunnya ayat akan membantu kita memahami hukum dalam alquran bukan dengan menterjemah secara literal sahaja
Mohd Nasarruddin said...
Pak Yeh jawab: Apa daa.? bagi komen kosong keranag kepala kamu kosong ka.? Bahas las. Bagi bukti hadith2 itu benar2 dari mulut nabi dan bukan dari mulut orang2 yang hidup 200 thaun selepas nabi wafat dan tak pernah melihat dan mendengar nabi.
Boleh percaya ke hadisth orang2 200 tahun yang kata nabi kawin dgn Aisha pada masa dia hanya 6 tahun dan sontot Aishah masa dia berumur 9 tahun. Nabi kamu halal dan sunahkan pedophile ke.??? Quran kata hanga kawainkan perempua2 yang matang. Apa nabi kamu tak ikut Quran ke. Hadith macam ni memburokkan nabi dan Islam.
Blogger kiedentech said...
Pak Yeh jawab: Apa daa.? bagi komen kosong keranag kepala kamu kosong ka.? Bahas las. Bagi bukti hadith2 itu benar2 dari mulut nabi dan bukan dari mulut orang2 yang hidup 200 thaun selepas nabi wafat dan tak pernah melihat dan mendengar nabi.
Boleh percaya ke hadisth orang2 200 tahun yang kata nabi kawin dgn Aisha pada masa dia hanya 6 tahun dan sontot Aishah masa dia berumur 9 tahun. Nabi kamu halal dan sunahkan pedophile ke.??? Quran kata hanga kawainkan perempua2 yang matang. Apa nabi kamu tak ikut Quran ke. Hadith macam ni memburokkan nabi dan Islam.
Bumi ni bentuk bulat ke mendatar wahai pakyeh. Jwb jgn xjwb
Hmmm...komen nk kena approve dulu ye. Fail blog ni. Takutkan perdebatan
Anonymous Anonymous said...
Bumi ni bentuk bulat ke mendatar wahai pakyeh. Jwb jgn xjwb
Pak Yeh jawab :
Apa daa.? Tanya soalan bodo pulak. Pelayar buat circumnavigation bermaana bumi itu bulatlah. Ada ayat Quran sebut Bumi tu bentok telur burung unta. Isu tu sudah di bahas oleh Dr Zakir Naik Ulama agama lahwal hadishadis lah.Boleh tengok kat youtube lah.
Rilex.. Org tanya. Tiba2 smua soalan dikatakan jahil, bodoh dll.
;)
Kalau nak ikut hadis, try this..
[mam Abu Suleman Jozjani told Muhammad bin Sa’d: I was in
the company of Imam Malik. Imam Malik was asked, “Can a man have rectal
intercourse with his wives?” Malik struck his head with his hand and
replied, “O Dummies! I am coming directly from bath after doing that. Don’t
you read in the Quran that your wives are your fields, go into them as you
please?” (‘Amdatil Qari, Tafsir Bukhari).]
Nak ikut hadis, try this...
[mam Abu Suleman Jozjani told Muhammad bin Sa’d: I was in
the company of Imam Malik. Imam Malik was asked, “Can a man have rectal
intercourse with his wives?” Malik struck his head with his hand and
replied, “O Dummies! I am coming directly from bath after doing that. Don’t
you read in the Quran that your wives are your fields, go into them as you
please?” (‘Amdatil Qari, Tafsir Bukhari).]
Post a Comment